Book Talk: High Five for Villainy
It’s tough to find a good villain nowadays. I blame it on psychology, muddying the
waters with motivational and emotional issues to explain away actions. Enough
of that nonsense. I want my villain to be bad all the way through. Discovering
Voldemort had been the abused child Tom Riddle tainted his death at the end. I’ll even admit to
a cheer when Dumbledore plummeted out the window. With Tom's tragic past evident, Dumbledore became an arrogant ass who should have been banned from
being around children decades before. After all, he had also allowed Harry to be raised by tormenting sadists who kept him in a closet. If only he had
gotten Tom counseling at the start, none of the resulting mayhem would
have happened. Frankly, I would gladly have pushed Dumbledore out the window
myself.
I
don’t want my villains redeemed, either. They should be bad all the way
through. Once redeemed, they evoke sympathy and teeter on becoming a hero. If
they’re punished, I don’t get that gleeful feeling of righteous satisfaction
anymore. I love that feeling. One of my favorite childhood villains was the
Wicked Witch of the West. What can be more evil than someone bent on destroying
a ten year-old child? Did I cry when she melted? Hell no. Recent writers have
delved into a fictional past to explain away her evilness. Pah! I don’t care.
Be rotten. Stay rotten. That’s my motto.
Tut,
tut, you say. A purely evil villain is only for children’s stories. In order
for an adult to enjoy a book, one must understand the character’s motivation.
What makes them tick? What is their background? Their psychological imperative?
Hell no. Exceptional villains abound in fiction; Count Dracula,
Professor Moriarty, the White Witch from the Chronicles of Narnia, Sauron from
The Lord of the Rings, Shakespeare’s Richard III. You’ll note, some were
written specifically for children, but some are for adults. All are great fun.
In
my opinion, one of the most compelling scenes in all literature is the meeting
between Richard III and Lady Anne. She’s a grieving widow and hates him—I mean
really, really hates him. After all, Richard is responsible for the death of
her husband and father. No way will she have anything to do with the conniving
hunchback, but as his charming lies unfold, he wins her over with pleas of love
and repentance. After she leaves, Richard gleefully admits in his soliloquy
he’s going to drop her like a hot rock as soon as gets what he wants. What a
scumbag. I adore him.
Keep
your psychological explanations. Enjoy your philosophical discussions of right
and wrong without me. I want my villains to get their due comeuppance at the
end and feel satisfaction as they meet their doom. (I insist on doom, too.) My
favorite villain from the movies was Hans Gruber in Die Hard; handsome,
charming, debonair, and one nasty son of a bitch at heart. He was not just bad.
He was gleefully bad. Maybe because Mummy never made his favorite pudding and
Daddy wouldn’t buy him a puppy. I don’t know. I don’t care. Every time Hans
plummets to his death at the end of the movie my heart sings. Take that Anakin
Skywalker and your wussy abandonment issues. Take that.
L.A. Kelley is a co-blogger at The Book Cove and writes books with adventure, humor, and romance with a touch of sass. Find her at http://lakelleythenaughtylist.blogspot.com
LOL. I LOVED this post. Seriously - it did make me LOL. I'm so glad to see that I'm not the only one who struggles with villains because, honestly, I just want them to be bad because they're bad. Totally with you on this one. :)
ReplyDeleteThanks, Abigail. Meet you on the dark side.
ReplyDeleteTrue all of the way through! While I like depth and thought behind characters, sometimes I just want them to hold true to their evilness and not play the guilt/sympathy card!
ReplyDelete~Jessi
Going off your comment about doom - that seems to be a common missing part in many stories lately! Just when you think something/someone is about to meet its maker, deservedly so, they someone mange to gain a faint beat in their Grinch heart and the story becomes puppies and rainbows. UGH
ReplyDelete